• Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • News
  • Review Directory
  • Advertise on B2G
  • About B2G
A B2G Marketing Services brand
Saturday, May 27, 2023
Back2Gaming
Ascend the throne of gaming with GIGABYTE
ADVERTISEMENT
  • PC Hardware
    • All
    • Accessories
    • Cases
    • Components
    • Cooling
    • Media Players
    • Networking
    • Notebooks & Laptops
    • Peripherals
    • Storage
    • Systems & Barebones
    black game controller on white surface

    Top Tech Trends Used For Creating a More Engaging Online Gaming Experience

    NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

    NVIDIA Debuts New Testing Tools For In-Depth Performance Testing

    NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

    NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

    NVIDIA LDAT cover image

    NVIDIA LDAT: System Latency Testing Made Easy

    Powenetics System: Accurate Component-Level Power Draw Measurement

    Powenetics System: Accurate Component-Level Power Draw Measurement

    Top 6 Reasons to Buy a Smartwatch

    Top 6 Reasons to Buy a Smartwatch

    NVIDIA Brings VR to SEA

    The Future of Virtual Reality

    Has Virtual Reality Finally Gone Mainstream?

    Are VR Games Here to Stay?

    havit-e30-tws-bluetooth-speaker-30w-pair-v5-wireless

    Review – HAVIT E30 TWS Bluetooth Speaker

    Trending Tags

      • CPU & Motherboards
      • Graphics Cards
      • Memory
      • Laptops
      • Cooling
      • Cases
      • More Hardware Reviews
    • Playstation
      Sony PSVR2 Virtual Reality Headset Review: A Generational Leap in Fidelity and Clarity

      Sony PSVR2 Virtual Reality Headset Review: A Generational Leap in Fidelity and Clarity

      Returnal PC Performance Review - returnal

      Returnal PC Performance Review

      How To Play Casino Games on PlayStation — 4-Step Guidance - returnal

      How To Play Casino Games on PlayStation — 4-Step Guidance

      PlayStation VR2 Launches Worldwide with Dozens of Launch Titles

      PlayStation VR2 Launches Worldwide with Dozens of Launch Titles

      God of War Ragnarok (PS5) Review

      God of War Ragnarok (PS5) Review

      Upcoming Games for PS5 to Watch for in 2023

      Upcoming Games for PS5 to Watch for in 2023

      The Last of Us Part I (PS5) Review

      The Last of Us Part I (PS5) Review

      New PlayStation Plus Subscription Plan is Now Rolling Out

      What Can Gaming Fans Expect from the PS Plus Premium Package?

      New PlayStation Plus Subscription Plan is Now Rolling Out

      PSN – a Must-Have for Gamers

    • Games
      • PC
      • Mobile
      • Xbox
      • Nintendo Switch
    • Gadgets
      • Smartphones
    • Guides
      • All
      • Ask B2G
      • PC Build Guides
      • Tweaks & Fixes
      Gaming Setup Essentials – Things You Must Need

      The Gear You Need For The Best Gaming Experience

      ROG Ally FAQs

      ROG Ally FAQs

      person holding white and blue click pen

      How To Attain A Larger And More Loyal Customer Base

      Tips for Successful Trading in CS:GO

      Tips for Successful Trading in CS:GO

      black flat screen computer monitor turned on beside black computer keyboard

      Beginners: How to Prepare Your First Gaming PC for Online Action

      woman in black hoodie standing in front of arcade machine

      Complete Guide to Playing Online Slots

      How to Take a Screenshot on a Windows Laptop - Easy & Quick - returnal

      How to Take a Screenshot on a Windows Laptop – Easy & Quick

      Sitting Too Much? How to Combat Back Pain and Improve Posture

      Sitting Too Much? How to Combat Back Pain and Improve Posture

      MSI-AMD Socket AM5 2023 Build Recommendations

      MSI-AMD Socket AM5 2023 Build Recommendations

      Trending Tags

        • PC Build Guides
      • Movies
        The First Slam Dunk (2022) Movie Review

        The First Slam Dunk (2022) Movie Review

        Kamen Rider BLACK SUN (Series) Review

        Kamen Rider BLACK SUN (Series) Review

        silhouette photography of man

        Best Spy Movies of All Time

        brown cardboard box with yellow light

        Skydance Animation and John Lasseter Announces Hiring of Former All-Star Disney Team

        Top Asian Gambling Films You Should Check Now

        Top Asian Gambling Films You Should Check Now

        person holding remote pointing at TV

        5 Best Drama Films to watch on Netflix based on IMDb’s rating

        the big bang theory dvd

        Gamble Like 007: Favorite Casino Scenes in James Bond Movies

        Integrating Innovation: Film Industry & Web 3.0

        Integrating Innovation: Film Industry & Web 3.0

        photo of library with turned on lights

        Three of the Best Book-to-Film Adaptations

      • Hobby & Entertainment
        • Anime & Manga
        • Gaming
        • WWE
        • MNL48
        • Toys & Collectibles
      No Result
      View All Result
      • PC Hardware
        • All
        • Accessories
        • Cases
        • Components
        • Cooling
        • Media Players
        • Networking
        • Notebooks & Laptops
        • Peripherals
        • Storage
        • Systems & Barebones
        black game controller on white surface

        Top Tech Trends Used For Creating a More Engaging Online Gaming Experience

        NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

        NVIDIA Debuts New Testing Tools For In-Depth Performance Testing

        NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

        NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

        NVIDIA LDAT cover image

        NVIDIA LDAT: System Latency Testing Made Easy

        Powenetics System: Accurate Component-Level Power Draw Measurement

        Powenetics System: Accurate Component-Level Power Draw Measurement

        Top 6 Reasons to Buy a Smartwatch

        Top 6 Reasons to Buy a Smartwatch

        NVIDIA Brings VR to SEA

        The Future of Virtual Reality

        Has Virtual Reality Finally Gone Mainstream?

        Are VR Games Here to Stay?

        havit-e30-tws-bluetooth-speaker-30w-pair-v5-wireless

        Review – HAVIT E30 TWS Bluetooth Speaker

        Trending Tags

          • CPU & Motherboards
          • Graphics Cards
          • Memory
          • Laptops
          • Cooling
          • Cases
          • More Hardware Reviews
        • Playstation
          Sony PSVR2 Virtual Reality Headset Review: A Generational Leap in Fidelity and Clarity

          Sony PSVR2 Virtual Reality Headset Review: A Generational Leap in Fidelity and Clarity

          Returnal PC Performance Review - returnal

          Returnal PC Performance Review

          How To Play Casino Games on PlayStation — 4-Step Guidance - returnal

          How To Play Casino Games on PlayStation — 4-Step Guidance

          PlayStation VR2 Launches Worldwide with Dozens of Launch Titles

          PlayStation VR2 Launches Worldwide with Dozens of Launch Titles

          God of War Ragnarok (PS5) Review

          God of War Ragnarok (PS5) Review

          Upcoming Games for PS5 to Watch for in 2023

          Upcoming Games for PS5 to Watch for in 2023

          The Last of Us Part I (PS5) Review

          The Last of Us Part I (PS5) Review

          New PlayStation Plus Subscription Plan is Now Rolling Out

          What Can Gaming Fans Expect from the PS Plus Premium Package?

          New PlayStation Plus Subscription Plan is Now Rolling Out

          PSN – a Must-Have for Gamers

        • Games
          • PC
          • Mobile
          • Xbox
          • Nintendo Switch
        • Gadgets
          • Smartphones
        • Guides
          • All
          • Ask B2G
          • PC Build Guides
          • Tweaks & Fixes
          Gaming Setup Essentials – Things You Must Need

          The Gear You Need For The Best Gaming Experience

          ROG Ally FAQs

          ROG Ally FAQs

          person holding white and blue click pen

          How To Attain A Larger And More Loyal Customer Base

          Tips for Successful Trading in CS:GO

          Tips for Successful Trading in CS:GO

          black flat screen computer monitor turned on beside black computer keyboard

          Beginners: How to Prepare Your First Gaming PC for Online Action

          woman in black hoodie standing in front of arcade machine

          Complete Guide to Playing Online Slots

          How to Take a Screenshot on a Windows Laptop - Easy & Quick - returnal

          How to Take a Screenshot on a Windows Laptop – Easy & Quick

          Sitting Too Much? How to Combat Back Pain and Improve Posture

          Sitting Too Much? How to Combat Back Pain and Improve Posture

          MSI-AMD Socket AM5 2023 Build Recommendations

          MSI-AMD Socket AM5 2023 Build Recommendations

          Trending Tags

            • PC Build Guides
          • Movies
            The First Slam Dunk (2022) Movie Review

            The First Slam Dunk (2022) Movie Review

            Kamen Rider BLACK SUN (Series) Review

            Kamen Rider BLACK SUN (Series) Review

            silhouette photography of man

            Best Spy Movies of All Time

            brown cardboard box with yellow light

            Skydance Animation and John Lasseter Announces Hiring of Former All-Star Disney Team

            Top Asian Gambling Films You Should Check Now

            Top Asian Gambling Films You Should Check Now

            person holding remote pointing at TV

            5 Best Drama Films to watch on Netflix based on IMDb’s rating

            the big bang theory dvd

            Gamble Like 007: Favorite Casino Scenes in James Bond Movies

            Integrating Innovation: Film Industry & Web 3.0

            Integrating Innovation: Film Industry & Web 3.0

            photo of library with turned on lights

            Three of the Best Book-to-Film Adaptations

          • Hobby & Entertainment
            • Anime & Manga
            • Gaming
            • WWE
            • MNL48
            • Toys & Collectibles
          No Result
          View All Result
          Back2Gaming
          No Result
          View All Result
          Home Reviews PC Hardware

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

          BossMac Suba by BossMac Suba
          September 9, 2020
          in PC Hardware
          Reading Time: 8 mins read
          A A
          0
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          Share Tweet
          ADVERTISEMENT

          Yesterday we posted about our power measurement tool, Powenetics and noted that it has changed the way we address the problem of accuracy of power draw particularly for GPUs. For the longest time, reviewers have relied on complicated meter setups and assumed readings from API and power outlets. I’ve always preferred reproducible numbers that can be tested via peers or by the readers but aforementioned power measurement methods have their own issues to deal with and Powenetics may have improved that for us but its barrier to entry still leaves as a premium solution. Still, the concept exists and the concept works; measuring power draw as it is being drawn directly from the device itself is a the most logical way to measure power draw and this echoes true for NVIDIA as today, they are making their PCAT (Power Capture Analysis Tool) testing tool public.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          Members of the press were issued the LDAT and PCAT kits prior to the announcement of the RTX 30 series graphics cards. We have coverage for LDAT as well as FrameView v1.1 in their own articles, make sure to check those out if you’re interested.

          ADVERTISEMENT

          Going back to PCAT, it arrives in a simple kit as below:

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          It comes with the PCAT mainboard, three PCIe 8/6-pin cables, a USB cable, a PCIe riser card, a connector cable for the riser card and mainboard and a couple of extended standoffs.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          The kit is easily assembled into the image above where a row of input cables connects to your PCIe power cables and the PCIe riser sits between the GPU and motherboard. NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          And here PCAT side-by-side with Powenetics. My setup is messy already but you can see which cleans up better between the two. I’ll get down to head-to-head comparison later on this article but for now, PCAT is looking pretty clean and if GPU-only reading is needed, this is pretty much everything you have to setup. I’d like to note that PCAT doesn’t work with the screws for OpenBenchTable.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          The back of the PCAT mainboard is covered with a 3D-printed layer for cover to prevent the solder points from making contact when laid flat. Make sure though that the PCIe power connectors’ exposed pins don’t make contact withe conductive objectives or you may risk a short or even worse.

          The mainboard can connect to a secondary system or the tested system itself. As the load is quite low, it does not matter where you use it for making readouts.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          There is also an LCD screen onboard. It doesn’t have any control but cycles through total power draw and the individualized list.

          PCAT Software

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          PCAT’s software is actually only comprised of a single screen. In the image above you can see a setup with the PCAT board connected to the test system.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          Here’s a shot of the PCAT software. The interface is just a single screen which has graphs for the current total power as well as per rail consumption which you can toggle in-between. Moving over to the upper part of the screen we have the summary total of power draw along with the min/max/avg power draw. Alongside that is a row of readings for each rail with its own breakdown of the voltage, current and wattage of each line. This is useful when trying to identify a specific draw like in the case of the RX 480 reported sipping more than 75W from the PCIe slot, we can read that here. Other than that we have controls like resetting the data, resetting the PCAT board itself, hiding the graphs etc. The important part here is data logging.

          PCAT keeps a CSV log for you but since there is not hotkey we’ll have to align data manually. That said, let’s move on data usage.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          Sample PCAT Power Draw Chart

          The chart above shows the power draw of an RTX 2080 Ti logged during a Final Fantasy XV Benchmark run in 4K High Detail. We captured this a few seconds before the benchmark and kept it idle after so you can see the difference between idle and load power over time. This is a great tool for performing and making profile readings of specific loads. Other than that, we can take the log and create various visualizations of the chart data like a simple bar chart for Min/Max/Avg readings.

          Power draw varies by application. Your GPU’s power draw when watching a video, playing a game and doing absolutely nothing will be different from another. This also varies between systems and graphics card. An RTX 2080 will draw less power than an RTX 2080 Ti. When presenting power data, its important to identify power draw to a specific applications. Due to the limitation of my system draw reading as well as API reading, it’s not possible to get a concrete reading of how much power your GPU is using on specific use cases. That said, PCAT has full integration with the new FrameView v1.1 from NVIDIA and we have an article covering the updates on that so check out here.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          In FrameView v1.1 we have access to PPW or performance-per-watt and when using the FrameView v1.1 Analyzer, we have the option of using PCAT to see the PPW specific to that benchmark:

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement 56

          With PCAT selected, we have access to this chart in the FrameView v1.1 Analyzer template:

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement 57

          This chart shows us the variance that may be shown from the API versus PCAT as the chart above shows. Here we have the same benchmark from above but notice how its reflecting a much more steady reading thru the API versus the PCAT reading. We also get some outliers during the beginning of the benchmark which occurred twice on PCAT but not as significant as it is on the API reading. This is important to note because if the outliers are reproducible, it may help in analyzing the cause but with an API reading, it may go completely ignored.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement 58

          As mentioned earlier, Performance-Per-Watt is one of the greatest and potentially the most important metric possible with this tool and with the help of FrameView v1.1 helps us make a visual of how much our GPUs work and how much work they actually put in compared to the out.

          PCAT vs Powenetics

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          In terms of usability, both power measurement solution are functional. Powenetics offers extensive power reading both CPU usage as well as ATX (SATA/MOLEX) power making it a much better solution for taking readings of multiple components. PCAT on the other hand is a GPU power draw measurement solution which means it only does one thing, and it does that good as well.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          Comparing both from a GPU power measurement perspective, PCAT automatically wins by default for the simple fact that it has integration with FrameView v1.1 which allows reviewers to plot data much easier. Powenetics has a manual logging tool and any manipulation of data or aligning has to be done from the ground up. Any kind of automation has to be bespoke as well. When making this article, I noticed that by default, PCAT and Powenetics do not gather data at the same rate so resulting data is logged in different timings. This makes it difficult aligning data for direct comparison. Powenetics’ advantage here is that you can configure it through the options. PCAT does not have this option. Although again, it is timed along with FrameView making it functionally more useful when making line charts.

          Installation also favors PCAT. The ready-made board and 3D-printed board cover makes it easy to place anywhere on a bench or case. Powenetics’ bricklets requires explicit placement. And is primarily limited to only an open test bench scenario. Ultimately, PCAT wins here for sheer ease of use and installation.

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          PCAT
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal
          Powenetics

          Last up is the software. PCAT is plain and straight forward. Powenetics comprehensive and also straightforward with this information but is also peppered with some other functionalities. Features like charting are simplistic vs. the entire functionality of the set. 

          Still, both products have their strength of the other and while it is quite obvious the GPU readout functionality of PCAT and to match that FPS information makes it an extensively useful tool, Powenetics CPU and ATX measurement readout and tools make it the far more extensive tool in terms of testing versatility and application.

          Standardized Power Measurements

          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement - returnal

          As more and more solutions for power measurement becomes available, access to such hardware will be much more prevalent and therefore should provide reviewers and ultimately end-users the tools they need for a more comprehensive benchmarking ecosystem. The endgame here is that with information such as power draw becoming more visible for user to gauge, efficiency will now become an important factor and there will be no more excuse to justify higher power draw for brute raw power. 

          I hope you are all as excited as I am for gaming technology in the coming months. Its definitely going to be a big year for gaming and even a bigger year afterwards. 

          Tags: accurate power consumption testingaccurate power draw testinggpu power draw testingmeasuring gpu power cosumption
          ShareTweetSendScan
          ADVERTISEMENT
          Previous Post

          NVIDIA LDAT: System Latency Testing Made Easy

          Next Post

          NVIDIA Debuts New Testing Tools For In-Depth Performance Testing

          BossMac Suba

          BossMac Suba

          My favorite animal is the scapegoat.

          Related Posts

          Lexar CFexpress Type A Professional GOLD Series Card Review
          Reviews

          Lexar CFexpress Type A Professional GOLD Series Card Review

          by BossMac Suba
          May 25, 2023
          0

          Easily the most affordable CFexpress Type-A card available right now. The Lexar CFexpress Type A Professional GOLD Series Card will let you utilize the full...

          High Growth Expectations are Fueling Network Security Investment by Communication Service Providers Worldwide
          Networking

          High Growth Expectations are Fueling Network Security Investment by Communication Service Providers Worldwide

          by BossMac Suba
          May 11, 2023
          0

          Global research from A10 Networks reveals priorities, expectations and perspectives of communication service providers

          close up photography of mining rig

          Kentucky Residents Receiving Better Access To The World Wide Web

          May 3, 2023
          ASUS RTX 4070 DUAL 12GB Graphics Card Review

          ASUS RTX 4070 DUAL 12GB Graphics Card Review

          April 12, 2023
          Next Post
          NVIDIA PCAT: A More Accurate Approach in Graphics Card Power Measurement

          NVIDIA Debuts New Testing Tools For In-Depth Performance Testing

          What Is the Best Online Casino to Play Slots

          What Is the Best Online Casino to Play Slots

          Hottest Games to be Released Throughout Autumn 2020

          Hottest Games to be Released Throughout Autumn 2020

          Leave a Reply Cancel reply

          Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

          Events

          ADVERTISEMENT
          • Contact Us
          • Latest News
          • Reviews Directory
          • Advertise on B2G
          • About Back2Gaming
          • OSRS Gold
          • WotLK Classic Gold
          Back2Gaming © 2022
          Reigning. Defending. Undisputed.
          No Result
          View All Result
          • PC Hardware
            • CPU & Motherboards
            • Graphics Cards
            • Memory
            • Laptops
            • Cooling
            • Cases
            • More Hardware Reviews
          • Playstation
          • Games
            • PC
            • Mobile
            • Xbox
            • Nintendo Switch
          • Gadgets
            • Smartphones
          • Guides
            • PC Build Guides
          • Movies
          • Hobby & Entertainment
            • Anime & Manga
            • Gaming
            • WWE
            • MNL48
            • Toys & Collectibles

          Back2Gaming © 2022